Outcomes Magazine

Feature

Know Them. Lead Better.

By Mychal Ann Druba

Back to listing

A healthy culture is personal.

Every Christian nonprofit has a culture, shaped not only by its mission statements, strategic plans, and stated values, but also by how employees experience leadership each day. Listening to what employees need helps leaders turn those values into practice. They do so through the way they deliver feedback, handle conflict, clarify expectations, and offer support.

Those everyday interactions determine whether people trust one another enough to carry out the organization’s strategy together. That is the influence captured in the familiar phrase “culture eats strategy for breakfast.”

For Christian organizations, this connection goes deeper: our internal culture is part of our witness and ministry.

For Christian organizations, this connection goes deeper: our internal culture is part of our witness and ministry. Employees should experience the same dignity, truth, grace, and accountability that we seek to express through our mission.

Philippians 2:3-4 calls believers to “in humility value others above yourselves,” attending to others’ interests rather than only their own. For leaders, that humility begins with asking what employees need rather than assuming we already know.

Responding to those needs does not mean leading everyone the same way. Consistency matters in expectations, policies, and fairness, but consistency is not sameness. Healthy leadership maintains clear standards while adapting communication, coaching, and support to help each person meet them.

Embrace the limits of one-size-fits-all leadership.

Most leaders have a default style. Some are direct and decisive. Others are relational and encouraging. Some prefer frequent collaboration, while others show confidence by giving employees room to work independently. None of these approaches is automatically right or wrong. The risk comes when leaders assume the style that works for them will work for everyone else.

Consider an annual review. One employee may be genuinely pleased to receive a “meets expectations” rating accompanied by specific positive feedback. They hear stability, appreciation, and confidence. Another employee may hear the same rating as a warning that their work is not valued, or that advancement is unlikely. The words have not changed, but the meaning received is completely different.

When leaders miss these differences, employees can feel misunderstood even when the leader had good intentions. Feedback may be filtered out, accountability may feel inconsistent, and development opportunities may be lost. Over time, that disconnect can weaken engagement, increase avoidable turnover, and raise the real cost of running the organization through vacancies, retraining, rework, and lost institutional knowledge.

Start with what people need.

Start with the employee’s’ need, not the leader’s preferred approach. Supportive, direct, collaborative, and autonomous approaches can all be useful, but they describe leadership behavior rather than the need underneath it. Ask what people need to do their best work, then learn how strongly each need shows up for the individual in front of you.

Edward Deci and Richard Ryan’s “Self-Determination Theory” identifies three basic human needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. These needs impact motivation, performance, and well-being.

  • Autonomy and trust. Give employees meaningful ownership over how they work while maintaining clear accountability. Let employees choose how to complete an assignment.
  • Competence and growth. Build confidence and capability through clear expectations, useful feedback, and opportunities to grow. Show employees how to improve.
  • Relatedness, or belonging and connection. Help employees feel they matter by listening, checking in, and living the organization’s values. Connect daily work to mission and impact.

Safety, employee voice, and recognition also help build a healthy culture.

Employees need to know they can speak openly and that their leaders will listen.

Employees need to know they can speak openly and that their leaders will listen. Make room for questions, mistakes, and respectful disagreement without humiliation or punishment.

The need to know our contribution was seen may be common, but meaningful recognition is personal. One employee may value public affirmation; another may prefer a private, specific note from a leader they respect. Recognition should reflect the individual rather than follow a one-size-fits-all approach.

Ask before you assume.

Leaders do not need a complicated assessment to begin. They need curiosity, observation, and consistent conversation.

James 1:19 urges believers to be “quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry.” In employee conversations, put that counsel into practice: ask, listen without interrupting, and check your understanding before responding.

Ask questions such as:

  • What helps you process feedback?
  • Do you prefer time to think or talk in the moment?
  • What makes recognition meaningful?
  • When you are stuck, what support helps?
  • How much direction do you want at a project’s start?
  • What could I do differently to help you succeed?

Listening helps leaders distinguish a genuine human need from a preferred working method.

Asking communicates respect and provides practical information, but it does not promise that every preference will be met. Leaders must still make decisions, address concerns, and balance individual needs with fairness, sound judgment, the organization’s practical needs and broader mission. The needs of the entire leadership team must also be considered.

Adapt the delivery, not the standard.

Adaptive leadership is not avoiding hard conversations or giving different employees different rules. Healthy culture requires clear expectations, equitable decisions, and honest accountability. The standard should remain steady. The delivery can change.

Two employees who miss a deadline need the same clarity: “The report was due Tuesday, and it was not submitted. I need the completed report by noon tomorrow and a plan to prevent this from happening again.” One may be ready to act on that direct statement. Another may need a brief opportunity to process what happened and identify barriers. Both conversations name the gap, set the expectation, and require follow-through. The leader adapts how each person is helped to hear and act on the message, not the standard itself.

This is consistent with the biblical call to communicate in ways that build others up. Ephesians 4:29 instructs believers to speak “only what is helpful for building others up according to their needs, that it may benefit those who listen.” According to their needs does not mean saying only what is comfortable. It means considering what will genuinely help the listener grow.

Turn understanding into a leadership rhythm.

Personalized leadership should not depend on memory or mood. In one-on-ones, ask what support is needed. At a project’s start, clarify the outcome, authority, check-in rhythm, and communication channel. After difficult conversations, summarize expectations and confirm next steps. During reviews, explain ratings with examples.

The support each person needs may change as their confidence, responsibilities, and circumstances evolve. Revisit what you learn rather than treating your understanding of an employee as fixed. The goal is a relationship informed by ongoing listening.

Culture is built one interaction at a time.

Healthy organizational culture is not created through a single retreat, value statement, or appreciation event. It is formed through repeated interactions that show what leadership is really like. Ask: Do leaders listen before responding? Do they tell the truth with care? Next consider: Do leaders recognize individual strengths? Do they provide both grace and accountability?

Christian leaders are called to steward people, not simply manage output. That requires humility, curiosity, and a willingness to adjust.

This week, choose one employee and ask what helps them receive feedback, stay motivated, and do their best work. Listen closely, make one meaningful adjustment, and follow up to ask whether it helped.

Culture change often begins with one leader choosing to know a person more deeply to lead them more intentionally.

###

Mychal Ann Druba is the Senior HR Director at Missionwell, LLC, where she helps nonprofits strengthen culture, develop leaders and build practical people practices that support mission and accountability. Missionwell provides finance, accounting, human resources, corporate and board services to nonprofit organizations. Learn more at www.missionwell.com.

Outcomes Conference: Mychal Ann Druba will co-lead a workshop entitled “Know Them. Lead Better.” at The Outcomes Conference 2027, April 6-8 in Jacksonville. Register Here >>

Share article