People Management & Care October 23, 2026

Hiring Staff: Four Critical Questions By Rev. Peter Corney and Dr. Ken Byrne

Back to Blog
Four Critical Questions: Hiring Process

Critical questions must come first in the hiring process.

You have a critical vacancy. You need to fill it as rapidly as possible. Not anyone will do.

You start by asking, “Is there someone we can promote?” “Do we know anyone?” or “How do we advertise?” Those are important secondary questions. Here are four questions to ask first.

Critical Question #1

“What are the consequences if we choose the wrong person?”

This is the single most important question to ask. Write the answer to this question in detail. It should then be the first page of a recruitment file.

A hiring mistake will always have an impact. Estimating the cost in dollar terms is easy. The real costs are much larger and harder to calculate. Consider these factors:

  • Impact on those you serve
  • Damage to your reputation
  • Potential damage to the culture you have been creating
  • Impact on your existing staff
  • Stress of the person managing a poor performer
  • Potential legal liability
  • Legal costs of separating from the problem performer.

The demands of day-to-day life prevent a careful analysis of what went wrong. Sure, there will be quiet hallway conversations, usually along the lines of “How did this person ever get hired?” Rarely does the analysis go much deeper. The focus naturally shifts to restarting the recruitment process.

Critical Question #2

“Where can I learn the fundamentals of hiring people?”

Hiring someone is easy. Hiring the right person is far more complex than most people appreciate.

No one is born knowing how to hire. People step into leadership roles, yet they rarely receive training in this critically important skill.

This need not be the case. There are many books on hiring. A few have been written for a Christian audience. Get one and read it. Then pick the highlights and study them.

Critical Question #3 

“What are the steps to select the best person?”

Proper selection usually follows a natural path. The basic steps are these:

  • Consider whether the role is vital to fill. Is there an alternative to hiring someone new?
  • If your answer is no, then choose who will be on the selection panel.

Choose carefully. You want people who:

  • Know the position
  • Are good judges of character
  • Can work collaboratively in a team
  • Can be trusted with confidential information.
  • Prepare a job description. Focus on the character of a successful applicant. Yes, skills are important. But usually not as important as you think.
  • The qualities that distinguish strong performers come built in with every applicant. People can learn new skills. You can’t teach kindness, work ethic, sensitivity to others, and many other factors.
  • Create a powerful attraction strategy. You must answer the question in every applicant’s mind: “Why should I apply?”

Critical Insight 3.1

When we spoke with the CEO of a Christian disability services agency, we asked, “Why would someone want to work here?” He responded by saying, “I have no idea. All we give people is hard work and not much pay.”

Clearly, some changes are important before they could start recruiting.

  • Decide how you will screen applicants. Tailor the approach to the number of people who apply. With a large number, you will need several steps to narrow the field to a short list of finalists.
  • Create a Structured Interview Guide. Fifty years of psychological research has repeatedly shown that unstructured interviews and casual chats strongly correlate with hiring mistakes.
  • The questions should be as short and simple as possible. Start with easy ones and gradually introduce more challenging ones. Remember that most questions will focus on the character of the applicant.
  • Conduct final interviews. It is always preferable to have at least two interviews. The more senior the job, the more important this is.

Depending on the job’s complexity, this may run from 60 to 120 minutes. Senior roles will often need three interviews.

  • Check references. Always. No exceptions. This should be a structured conversation with carefully worded, prepared questions, not a brief chat. Speak only with past supervisors. No relatives, friends, or coworkers need be involved. Someone on the hiring committee must do this.

Critical Question #4

“Where will we find the time?”

Hiring takes time. The more senior the role, the longer it takes. Trying to do it while still doing their regular jobs often leads to rushed decisions. People see the hiring process as a burden because they “have to get back to their real job.” Hiring quickly often leads to poor selection decisions.

There is no easy formula for creating time. The panel should solve this question at their first meeting.

Summary

Sharing the Good News of Jesus requires the right people. Choosing the best person for each role takes time, usually more than you thought at the start. The best people are essential to your mission’s success. This reduces your stress and makes your work more enjoyable. A hiring mistake is like a pebble in your shoe. Chronically irritating and difficult to dislodge.

“For the Lord sees not as man sees: man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart.”

1 Samuel 16:7


This material is adapted with permission from Hire Right, First Time: A Practical Guide to Staffing Christian Organisations. The book comes with a 200-page User Guide and is available from Amazon.

Rev. Peter Corney is an Anglican minister who has been actively involved in writing, teaching, and leadership development for the past sixty years.

Dr. Ken Byrne has been an independent organizational psychologist for over forty years. He has evaluated more than 3000 job applicants for both Christian and secular employers,


Searching for the right person or the right position? We are here to help!

Looking for a community that gets you. We help you find your people!

Looking for a way to renew your mind, heart, and soul. We’ve got you covered.

Share article

Membership Exclusives

Join CLA | Member Exclusives

Alliance 
Community

Collaborate with peers to share strategic advice, solve challenges, and develop new approaches. Safe, secure and available 24/7!

Outcomes 
Academy Online

Outcomes 
Academy Online

Home of the CLA Center for Online Learning, discover professional development that includes 10-week facilitated cohorts, high impact self-paced courses and short form on-demand inspirational content.

Join CLA Member Exclusives

Credential Christian Nonprofit Leader Program (CCNL)

Enroll in the CCNL credential program and gain a proven multi-disciplinary understanding of nonprofit leadership. Earn this distinction through online courses and attending the Outcomes Conference.