Skip to content

Time to Rethink Your Newsletters By Amy Sewell

The Search for More Effective Newsletters

Recently, we asked ourselves, “Is there a better way to do newsletters so they can have a greater impact on your donor file, while also increasing the funds they raise?


Typical eNewsletters for nonprofits consist of a single email with a brief intro from the organization’s leadership and a few highlighted articles, stories, or areas to take action. But this style of messaging relies on a single send date and time, and it requires people to click through individual articles to read the full stories.

What if that message hits at a bad time or someone isn’t pulled in by the title and blurb to click and read the rest of the content? We theorized that if we broke the same highlighted articles out into individual emails—sending three separate messages with only one article featured in each—we might be able to increase the number of people seeing the content and how many give.


  • Unique opens increased by 185%
  • Unique clicks increased by 329%
  • Revenue increased by 57%


Ultimately, more people got into the messages, read the full articles, and decided to give—I’d say that was a successful newsletter test! And thankfully, it’s easy to try out for your organization as well. If you have an eNewsletter, use the same content, split your list, and see how this works on your file.

It’s also worth mentioning that while the eNewsletter is an essential part of your communications plan, it doesn’t replace the printed newsletter. Your donors are connected to you in multiple ways and on multiple channels, so your stories of impact and reporting should take place in multiple locations as well.

We’ve worked with several organizations who have considered going entirely digital for their newsletters in hopes of saving costs—but doing so has a big reduction in the overall revenue your newsletter can bring. For example, when one of our clients decided to go fully digital, their eNewslettesr only generated 10% of what they typically received when also doing a mailing. This is why testing any major change is so important. Thankfully, this nonprofit went back to multi-channel communications, which reopened the door to the revenue they need to accomplish its mission.

Your donors care about the stories you have to share . . . they want to hear about how their donations are making a difference and how they can be part of what’s right with the world. However, they also choose very specific ways they prefer to connect with your organization—whether via print, email, or social networks. So, keep sending those great impact stories across all channels—and in digital, I hope you’ll try out this new format. You may be surprised by how a simple change can pay off in a big way.

P.S. Be sure check out this related post The Effective Fundraising Newsletter By Douglas Shaw


Amy Sewell has been working in the digital space for 22 years, and drives the strategy behind all the digital projects completed at Douglas Shaw & Associates. Amy has run social media programs reaching over 2 million followers on a regular basis, creating solutions on these networks that expand reach and create personal connections with supporters. Amy is driven by results and goes beyond engagement, utilizing social media to inspire donors and drive revenue.

Be inspired as you enjoy the Fall edition of Outcomes Magazine.

A Christian Leadership Alliance quarterly publication.


What is Christian Leadership Alliance?

Christian Leadership Alliance equips and unites leaders to transform the world for Christ. We are the leaders of Christ-centered organizations who are dedicated to faithful stewardship for greater kingdom impact.

Upcoming Events

Check back later!